| 2nd Period Play-by-Play |
| | Start of 2nd period [45:00]. |
| | For GEN: #33 Bryan Butler, #5 Keenan Barr, #15 Kyle Terrill, #8 Garrett Masters, #6 Ben Makin, #4 John Shipley, #10 T. Krzywiecki, #21 Garret Biese, #18 Jesse Herman. |
| | For GEN: #33 Bryan Butler, #5 Keenan Barr, #15 Kyle Terrill, #8 Garrett Masters, #6 Ben Makin, #4 John Shipley, #10 T. Krzywiecki, #21 Garret Biese, #18 Jesse Herman, #16 Jon Mathoslah. |
| | For GEN: #33 Bryan Butler, #5 Keenan Barr, #15 Kyle Terrill, #8 Garrett Masters, #6 Ben Makin, #4 John Shipley, #10 T. Krzywiecki, #21 Garret Biese, #18 Jesse Herman, #16 Jon Mathoslah, #11 Jeb Nash. |
| | For SVC: #1 Clemente Mejia, #4 Brody Ruffner, #17 Luke D'Amico, #7 Aaron Frech, #21 Gage Arnold, #8 Aaron Wilkinson, #22 Josue Cuadra, #11 Daniel Moore, #19 Michael Cerchione, #5 Christian Trueax, #16 Trevor Cutlip. |
| | Foul on Geneva College. |
| [47:33] | Shot by SVC Trevor Cutlip, SAVE Bryan Butler. |
| | Foul on Geneva College. |
| [49:02] | Shot by SVC Luke D'Amico WIDE LEFT. |
| [53:26] | Shot by SVC Josue Cuadra WIDE RIGHT. |
| [58:11] | Shot by GEN Keenan Barr HIGH. |
| | Foul on Saint Vincent. |
| [59:50] | SVC substitution: Constantine Barlamas for Christian Trueax. |
| [59:50] | SVC substitution: Elom Pedanou for Josue Cuadra. |
| [60:47] | Offside against Geneva College. |
| | Foul on Saint Vincent. |
| [63:14] | GEN substitution: Max Flick for Garrett Masters. |
| [63:14] | SVC substitution: Josue Cuadra for Daniel Moore. |
| [64:00] | Shot by GEN Jon Mathoslah HIGH. |
| | Foul on Saint Vincent. |
| [66:54] | Shot by GEN Keenan Barr, SAVE Clemente Mejia. |
| | Corner kick by GEN Jeb Nash [67:22]. |
| [67:25] | GEN substitution: David Gerlach for Ben Makin. |
| [67:50] | SVC substitution: Christian Trueax for Michael Cerchione. |
| [68:32] | Shot by SVC Brody Ruffner, SAVE Bryan Butler. |
| [70:35] | GOAL by GEN T. Krzywiecki, Assist by Jesse Herman, goal number 2 for season. |
| Saint Vincent 1, Geneva College 1 |
| [70:52] | GEN substitution: Ben Makin for Keenan Barr. |
| [72:11] | Shot by GEN Max Flick, SAVE Clemente Mejia. |
| [72:49] | GEN substitution: Garrett Masters for T. Krzywiecki. |
| [74:08] | Shot by GEN Jeb Nash, SAVE Clemente Mejia. |
| | Foul on Geneva College. |
| [75:14] | Shot by SVC Gage Arnold HIGH. |
| [75:42] | GEN substitution: Jon Sparks for Jeb Nash. |
| [76:05] | Header Shot by GEN Garrett Masters HIGH. |
| [76:22] | SVC substitution: Michael Cerchione for Elom Pedanou. |
| [77:09] | GOAL by GEN David Gerlach, Assist by Garrett Masters, goal number 2 for season. |
| Geneva College 2, Saint Vincent 1 |
| [79:04] | Shot by GEN Jeb Nash, SAVE Clemente Mejia. |
| [79:40] | Shot by SVC Josue Cuadra, SAVE Bryan Butler. |
| [80:40] | GEN substitution: Keenan Barr for Jon Mathoslah. |
| [81:58] | GOAL by SVC Michael Cerchione, Assist by Gage Arnold, goal number 3 for season. |
| Saint Vincent 2, Geneva College 2 |
| [82:35] | Shot by GEN Keenan Barr WIDE LEFT. |
| | Foul on Saint Vincent. |
| | Foul on Geneva College. |
| | Foul on Saint Vincent. |
| [84:43] | Yellow card on SVC Luke D'Amico. |
| [85:14] | Shot by GEN Ben Makin, SAVE Clemente Mejia. |
| [85:32] | GEN substitution: Jon Mathoslah for David Gerlach. |
| | Corner kick by GEN Jeb Nash [85:50]. |
| [85:52] | Header Shot by GEN Jon Mathoslah HIT CROSSBAR. |
| | Corner kick by GEN Jeb Nash [86:04]. |
| [86:29] | Header Shot by GEN Kyle Terrill HIGH. |
| [87:21] | GOAL by GEN T. Krzywiecki, Assist by Ben Makin, goal number 3 for season. |
| Geneva College 3, Saint Vincent 2 |
| [87:57] | Shot by SVC Luke D'Amico, SAVE Bryan Butler. |
| [88:17] | Offside against Geneva College. |
| [89:02] | GEN substitution: David Gerlach for Keenan Barr. |
| | End of period [90:00]. |